Welcome to Champ or Chump! We take an especially detailed take a look at a single participant per piece, incorporating info from in every single place we are able to consider to find out whether or not the featured participant is a champ or a chump in fantasy baseball. The largest sources are Baseball Savant and FanGraphs, however we additionally take a look at ADP information from FantasyPros, lineup info from RosterResource, rostered charges from Yahoo!, and information gadgets the place acceptable.
Whereas each fantasy analyst is specializing in potential early-season breakouts like Steven Kwan and Jeremy Pena, we will take a look at a reputation you most likely have not thought a lot about but to kick issues off: Carson Kelly. Kelly is the beginning catcher for the Arizona Diamondbacks, and you’ll be forgiven for those who did not see his stable line for the workforce final 12 months. In spite of everything, the D-Backs have been horrible!
Kelly has one stroll and no hits to his credit score up to now this season, so he is not making any headlines. Nevertheless, his peripherals recommend that he’ll hit nicely for a catcher, a place that fantasy managers constantly wrestle to fill with out overpaying for an enormous identify like Salvador Perez or J.T. Realmuto. With a 19% roster price, it might be prudent so as to add him to your roster earlier than he makes noise and your league mates discover him. Here is why:
Featured Promo: Get any full-season MLB and DFS Premium Cross for 50% off. Unique entry to our Group Sync platform, Premium articles, each day Matchup Ranking projections, 15 lineup instruments, DFS cheat sheets, Analysis Stations, Lineup Optimizers and rather more!
Signal Up Now!
Carson Kelly was chosen by the St. Louis Cardinals within the second spherical of the 2012 Newbie Draft and constantly cracked Baseball America’s top-10 record of Cardinals prospects whereas on the farm. He transformed to catcher in 2014 and shortly earned the approval of scouts for his defensive chops behind the dish, usually being named the highest defender in a company identified for instructing the basics. The D-Backs preferred what they noticed and requested for him within the blockbuster commerce that despatched Paul Goldschmidt to St. Louis.
Kelly has obtained a handful of MLB PAs each season since 2016, however he was underutilized early in his profession as an occasional backup to the rarely-rested Yadier Molina. As such, he has solely two seasons of at the very least 300 MLB PAs to his credit score: 2019 and 2021. The unusual factor is that he posted just about similar numbers in each circumstances.
In 2019, Kelly slashed .245/.348/.478 with 18 large flies over 365 PAs. His plate self-discipline was excellent with a 13.2 BB% backed by a superb 25% chase price, giving him added worth in OBP codecs but additionally contributing to his runs scored and BA potential. Kelly did not strikeout usually with a 21.6 Ok% and eight.6 SwStr%, and he took full benefit of his above-average 18.6% HR/FB with a 41.1 FB%. His .271 BABIP was unhealthy, but additionally form of anticipated once you run like a catcher.
In 2021, Kelly hit .240/.343/.411 with 13 HR in 359 PAs. His HR/FB declined to 12.6%, a drop-off probably defined by separate IL stints with toe and wrist fractures (wrist accidents specifically are identified to sap energy manufacturing). He nonetheless did a great job elevating the ball with a 43.8 FB%, flashed an amazing eye with a 12.3 BB% and 26.1% chase price, and saved the strikeouts in examine with a 20.6 Ok% and 9.9 SwStr%. His .270 BABIP was very near his 2019 mark as nicely.
Outdoors of some lacking homers, Kelly posted the identical season in each years. The similarities proceed for those who take a look at his superior metrics. Per Statcast, Kelly’s common airborne exit velocity was 92.4 mph in 2019 and 92.2 in 2021. His price of Brls/BBE was 8.5% in each years. His xBA marks have been .244 in 2019 and .251 final season. Briefly, we now have 724 PAs of an above-average offensive catcher with the defensive capacity to keep away from a timeshare. That is fantasy gold!
You’ll have seen that we skipped a season within the above evaluation. Kelly wasn’t good in 2020 with a .221/.264/.385 triple-slash line dragged down by a .250 BABIP and 4.7 BB%. That mentioned, 2020 was a wierd season for a number of causes and it appears honest to provide him a mulligan for a few unhealthy months. His eye got here again in 2021, and a .250 BABIP is low even for a gradual catcher weak to the shift like Kelly. This creator is assured that the 2019 and 2021 man with 20+ HR pop and robust OBP is the actual Carson Kelly.
A .240-.250 hitter with the potential to pop 20 homers would not be that thrilling in most lineups, however Kelly typically occupies an vital slot in Arizona’s batting order. He solely hit sixth on Opening Day, however hit third within the membership’s second recreation and fifth within the third. A sustained function in the midst of the lineup would enable Kelly to compile extra counting stats than most different catchers even in a weak D-Backs lineup, offering extra incentive to roster him.
For those who play DFS or in a league that encourages each day micromanagement, you may additionally have an interest to study that Kelly obliterates lefties. His profession triple-slash line towards southpaws is .277/.369/.526, making him an fascinating choice to differentiate your roster when deploying a well-liked stack.
Kelly is not a family identify but, however the 27-year-old could be by the tip of the season. Different catchers provide comparable energy, however Kelly combines it with plus OBP and respectable BA potential. His lineup function also needs to give him extra counting stat alternatives than gamers buried within the order. Kelly is nice in order for you a “do no hurt” catcher with out investing any draft day sources, making him a Champ price trying into in all two-catcher codecs and OBP leagues.
Obtain Our Free Information & Alerts Cell App
Like what you see? Obtain our up to date fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24×7 participant information, harm alerts, sleepers, prospects & extra. All free!